More Porsche Sales, More Poor Children, More Workers Without Full Time Jobs in BC - Something Wrong With This Picture

Porsche dealership in Vancouver - life is good!

When luxury car sales and unemployment spike simultaneously, something's amiss.

Bill Tieleman's 24 Hours Vancouver / The Tyee column

Tuesday April 1, 2014

By Bill Tieleman

"Social Acceptance: It is important to us that the Porsche brand is firmly anchored in society. And represents an attainable dream."

- Porsche Canada

Great news: Porsche sales went up 20 per cent in British Columbia in 2013.

But unfortunately, so did the number of poor children and people without full-time jobs!

And while it's good Porsche is concerned about the "social acceptance" of the cars it sells, starting from $54,000 for a Macan S to over $1 million for a 918 Spyder, something is wrong with this picture.

Sadly, a Porsche is an "attainable dream" for B.C.'s rich, but the hope of a full-time job and raising children without poverty is unattainable for hundreds of thousands of British Columbians.

And don't look to B.C. Premier Christy Clark's heavily-advertised BC Jobs Plan to change that -- BC Liberal "strategy" bets everything on the risky chance that liquefied natural gas will cure all.

On Monday, Clark and her five-minister entourage visited Ottawa to repeat claims that LNG will create 100,000 B.C. jobs.

However a RBC Capital Markets report released last week once again casts doubts on B.C.'s boasts.

"A window of opportunity exists for Canadian LNG projects to capture market share, but that opening is limited given intensifying supply competition from the United States, Russia, and Mozambique," the report says.

"While the global LNG market is likely to remain supply-constrained into 2018, demand growth limitations could play a much bigger role thereafter -- particularly if Japan's nuclear utilization rates rebound as we expect."

Meanwhile, back in the real world, child poverty, income disparity and job losses in B.C. simply grow and grow.

The rich, the poor, the Porsche

Look at the cold, hard numbers.

Statistics Canada reports that B.C.'s full-time employment dropped from 1,814,100 in Oct. 2013 to 1,802,700 in Feb. 2014.

Every other western province saw full-time employment grow during that period.

B.C.'s labour force actually shrank, while the employment rate dropped. Now, 157,500 workers are jobless. (Because of a lower participation rate -- people giving up on finding work -- the unemployment rate dipped slightly from 6.6 per cent in October to 6.4 per cent in February.)

Then look at B.C.'s pathetic child poverty record, Canada's worst again.

Youth advocate group First Call's report released late last year shows B.C.'s child poverty rate at 18.6 per cent, the highest in Canada and 5.3 per cent above than the national average, according to the latest StatsCan figures available.

That means one in five kids in B.C., about 153,000, live below StatsCan's low-income cutoff.

First Call points out that B.C. also has the most unequal distribution of income among rich and poor families with children.

The richest 10 per cent has 12.6 times the income of the poorest 10 per cent, the worst ratio in Canada.

But hey, no worries: Porsche sold 569 luxury cars in B.C. last year, a 20 per cent increase over 2012. Jaguar jumped 80 per cent, Land Rover 24 per cent and Audi 12 per cent -- and even Mercedes Benz moved 5,492 new models to rise three per cent.

And as a current radio ad cheerfully tells us: "Just like that, you can afford a Mercedes Benz!"

Unless, that is, you unfortunately happen to be unemployed or poor in British Columbia.

.

The confusing positions of Mike Harcourt - former BC NDP member - and former BC premier

Mike Harcourt, Darlene Marzari and Joy MacPhail - March 22, 2007

Mike Harcourt is a good guy - I've always liked him and found him to be a decent person in politics.

Which is why I'm very confused about his statements to the Globe and Mail newspaper saying he has let his BC New Democratic Party membership lapse because of three past events:  

1. The BC NDP opposing the unfair BC Liberal carbon tax in the 2009 provincial election.

2. The forced removal of former BC NDP leader Carole James in 2010 after she lost the 2005 and 2009 elections and indicated she would continue as leader in 2013.

3. BC NDP leader Adrian Dix's decision in mid-campaign of the 2013 election to reverse his position to wait and see the Kinder Morgan oil pipeline expansion application before deciding to support or oppose it and instead oppose it immediately.

I disagree with Mike Harcourt on the carbon tax - but that's four years ago and happened under Carole James.  The BC NDP did not oppose the carbon tax in the 2013 election under Adrian Dix.

That's a puzzling position for Harcourt to take.

I regret that Carole James did not make a decision to step down as leader after two election defeats and other issues but regardless of that, it happened three years ago.

Mike Harcourt endorsed MLA Mike Farnworth in the 2011 leadership campaign, so presumably the first two items were not reason to let his BC NDP membership expire and stay out of the leadership endorsement business.  [I endorsed Adrian Dix in 2011.]

That leaves the Kinder Morgan pipeline decision - and I agree with Mike Harcourt that it was a mistake - and I've written that here and in 24 Hours Vancouver and The Tyee several times since the election.

But Mike Harcourt doesn't agree with Mike Harcourt on Kinder Morgan!

At least, Harcourt now disagrees with Harcourt then.

Here's what Harcourt told CKNW's Bill Good on May 13, 2013 in a discussion of the election and the Kinder Morgan reversal:

Bill Good: "But Mr Dix had said for months that his principled position was to wait until an application had been made and then for there to be a proper review and suddenly he…."

Mike Harcourt: "That's not the issue. The issue is is this a good idea for an inner-city port in Vancouver, and the answer is no. There's a lot of really necessary port facilities, and we all understand how important the Vancouver Port Authority is."

"I was on the board for six years, so I know how key it is to the Canadian economy, and adding to the wheat and canola and the coal and all the other really important port facilities that are already in the Port of Vancouver and Burrard Inlet and putting a major oil export port there is, I think, a bad idea and you might as well let people know where you stand on that sooner rather than later." 

It's also sad to read a blog item I posted in March 2007 when Mike Harcourt brought down the house at a celebration of former NDP cabinet minister Darlene Marzari.

Here's what I wrote - and Mike said then:

But it was Harcourt's comments about some former premiers that brought roars from the crowd of mostly - but not all - longtime New Democrats.

"I'm one of the former NDP premiers who still holds a membership card," Harcourt quipped to howls of laughter. 

Take that Ujjal Dosanjh! Pow to you, Bob Rae!

I am disappointed that Mike Harcourt has now left the NDP.

But with reasons as confusing as these, I'm even more puzzled than disappointed.

.

On Gay Rights, NFL Has No Kluwe - Fired After Supporting Gay Marriage, Ex-Minnesota Vikings Punter Chris Kluwe Kicks Back in Vancouver

Ex-Minnesota Vikings punter Chris Kluwe speaks at SFU downtown in Vancouver March 18 - Bill Tieleman photo

Bill Tieleman talks with principled punter Chris Kluwe, who says social activism cost him his job.

Bill Tieleman’s 24 Hours Vancouver / The Tyee column

Tuesday March 25, 2014

By Bill Tieleman

"In the end, it's a choice between playing a children's game or standing up for human rights." 

- Chris Kluwe, Minnesota Vikings football player fired after supporting gay marriage

Would you give up a $1.45-million-a-year job playing professional football to publicly speak out in favour of gay marriage? Even though you are straight?

Former National Football League punter Chris Kluwe did.

And while Kluwe spoke at last week's Vancouver TED Talks conference, he pulled no punches when asked to respond to my criticism of TED's overzealous focus on corporate technology solving world problems.

That's no surprise from this outspoken guy, who in January wrote the stunningly provocative article titled: "I Was An NFL Player Until I Was Fired By Two Cowards And A Bigot."

Published on Deadspin, the story charged that Kluwe's refusal to be silent about gay rights cost him his job. It caused a huge international controversy, received over four million views, and helped earn Kluwe nearly 200,000 Twitter followers.

In person, Kluwe is no strident martyr. He's just an ordinary guy in shorts and sandals doing the right thing, with the platform to make it heard.

Talking at TED - And SFU

I met Kluwe last Tuesday when he agreed to speak to students at teacher Suzanne Norman's Simon Fraser University publishing class in downtown Vancouver.

He fielded questions from students, a player from the university's Clan football team, and myself.

Chris Kluwe & Bill Tieleman - Suzanne Norman photo

The 32-year-old punter who lives in California with his wife and two daughters said he loves Vancouver and would consider playing for the BC Lions.

Kluwe didn't hesitate when I asked if my criticism that the $7,500-per-person TED Talks that brought him here is far too fixated on corporate technology solutions to world problems.

"You can't have the belief that technology will solve everything. It gives you the possibility of making things worse," Kluwe responded. "There is a problem seeing technology as a panacea."

Kluwe's TED Talk last Wednesday wasn't about social activism; it was about augmented reality and his belief that technology can make football safer, including using tools like Google Glass to avoid career-ending concussions by giving players warning signs of impending collisions with tacklers.

By his own admission, Kluwe's future is unclear. He said he plans to play a lot of video games -- a Warcraft expert, his Twitter handle is @ChrisWarcraft -- stay in shape and write books for now. But he is still open to a return to football.

Letter to a 'narcissistic fromunda'

Kluwe became socially actively in 2012, after Maryland politician Emmett C. Burns Jr. attacked Baltimore Ravens linebacker Brendon Ayanbadejo for supporting a gay marriage initiative. Burns called on the owner of the team to "inhibit such expressions from your employee."

In response, Kluwe penned an eloquent open letter in Deadspin, which told Burns that his "vitriolic hatred and bigotry make me ashamed and disgusted to think that you are in any way responsible for shaping policy at any level."

Then, Kluwe went nuclear on Burns:

"As I suspect you have not read the Constitution, I would like to remind you that the very first, the VERY FIRST Amendment in this founding document deals with the freedom of speech, particularly the abridgment of said freedom.

"Not only are you clearly violating the First Amendment, you also come across as a narcissistic fromunda stain. What on earth would possess you to be so mind-bogglingly stupid?

"It baffles me that a man such as yourself, a man who relies on that same First Amendment to pursue your own religious studies without fear of persecution from the state, could somehow justify stifling another person's right to speech.

"To call that hypocritical would be to do a disservice to the word. Mindfucking obscenely hypocritical starts to approach it a little bit."

Then, Kluwe administered the coup de grace:

"I can assure you that gay people getting married will have zero effect on your life. They won't come into your house and steal your children. They won't magically turn you into a lustful cockmonster.

"They won't even overthrow the government in an orgy of hedonistic debauchery because all of a sudden they have the same legal rights as the other 90 per cent of our population -- rights like Social Security benefits, child care tax credits, Family and Medical Leave to take care of loved ones, and COBRA healthcare for spouses and children."

Burns was immolated as Kluwe's flame letter went viral, leading the Democrat to reconsider.

"Upon reflection, he has his First Amendment rights. And I have my First Amendment rights... Each of us has the right to speak our opinions. The football player and I have a right to speak our minds," Burns told media, but clearly Kluwe's free kick put Burns tumbling into the end zone.

'Great job on that letter, man!'

Kluwe knew he was onto something when a 290-pound tackler from an opposing team approached him at a game, causing some significant trepidation until the player said: "Great job on that letter, man!"

But the clueless NFL, in particular the Minnesota Vikings, didn't welcome the eight-year veteran's outspokenness.

Chris Kluwe - at SFU downtown - Bill Tieleman photo

Kluwe was cut by the Vikings in May 2013, a move the punter said was the culmination of repeated attempts to silence him, even though owner Zygi Wilf had personally told him he was free to speak out.

In Vancouver last week, Kluwe was philosophical about paying for his principles, but scathing about the NFL.

"A lot of it is the corporatization of football. They don't want to offend anyone," Kluwe said. "If they don't offend anyone, they'll buy more of our product.

"There are owners who will give a guy who committed a felony a second chance -- murder, drunk driving, spousal abuse," Kluwe said, referring to players like dog killer Michael Vick; Leonard Little, convicted of drunk driving manslaughter; and Ray Lewis, who had murder charges dropped after he agreed to testify against two friends.

All three and many others quickly returned to the NFL field. But speak out in favour of gays and lesbians being allowed to legally marry their partners? Forget it!

Interestingly, Kluwe said the big problem on gay marriage doesn't come from the players, but owners and coaches. "This is very much a generational issue, like racism," Kluwe said.

And he predicted the first openly gay player, college star Michael Sam, will do fine in the NFL once drafted in May.

"Michael Sam is a football player who happens to be gay. Sexuality has nothing more do with it than skin colour," Kluwe said. "I think he'll get a fair shake in NFL locker rooms."

Doing the right thing

Kluwe said he's not sure what's next, but he has started work on his football memoirs as well as a science fiction trilogy, and has already written BEAUTIFULLY UNIQUE SPARKLEPONIES, a 2013 book featuring his personal essays on various absurdities in football and beyond.

While he said that being cut by the Vikings was "bullshit," and that his wife was stressed out at the time, he is amazingly easygoing about it now.

"I honestly don't care. I don't need much to get by. I need a couch and an Internet connection," Kluwe said, though he admitted the NFL salary loss affects his kids' college fund.

When one SFU student asked Kluwe how speaking out impacted his endorsements, Kluwe laughed. "Hey man, punters don't get endorsements!" he replied.

But Kluwe turned deadly serious as well. "This isn't just something I had to go through -- millions of people face losing their jobs for being gay," Kluwe said.

"I'm 'that guy' who speaks out [about] a fairly basic concept: treat people the way you want to be treated. You learn that in kindergarten."

He concluded by noting that his two daughters learned an invaluable lesson from the controversy. "In the future when Dad says: 'Do the right thing,' they'll know I did," Kluwe said.

This political punter has one hell of an admirable kick.

.

VanCity Board of Director Elections March 31 to April 25 - I will be voting for Lily Grewal and Ellen Woodsworth

As a former Director of VanCity, I take a special interest in seeing good people elected to the Board of Canada's largest credit union - and the one I do business with.

Lily Grewal and son

There are several excellent candidates running for elections that start March 31 to April 25 but I want to highlight two that I will be voting for: Lily Grewal and Ellen Woodsworth.

Lily Grewal would be an impressive new voice on the Board, a Delta resident who brings a strong background of working with immigrant communities, unions, non-profits, social justice, cooperatives and much more.

Lily would also provide the VanCity Board with the needed perspective of those members who live south of the Fraser River.

Ellen Woodsworth

Ellen Woodsworth would bring a wealth of experience to VanCity - from sitting on Vancouver City Council for six years to working with seniors, fighting poverty and homelessness and standing up for a variety of progressive causes.

You can find out more about Lily and Ellen at their websites linked above and about the elections at VanCity's website.

In branch voting takes place from April 11 to 17 in select branches; other voting takes place by mail.

.

In support of Jenny Kwan, BC NDP MLA, who has done the right thing in difficult Portland Hotel Society situation

NDP MLA Jenny Kwan - centre - Bill Tieleman at right - at Fight HST rally with other NDP MLAs, September 2009

Much has already been said about the unfortunate circumstances surrounding the devastating audit of the Portland Hotel Society and in particular about BC NDP MLA Jenny Kwan - Vancouver Mount Pleasant - and her connection to the PHS audit.

Jenny immediately repaid nearly $35,000 to cover all possible costs of two trips where she and her family accompanied her former husband Dan Small - who was a PHS executive member and director of policy and research for the non-profit.  

That repayment, as outlined in her statement on March 21,  included his own travel costs - despite being assured that Jenny and her children's travel had been paid personally by Small.  

She did that to ensure that the Portland Hotel Society was in no way paying for her family's travel - it is a principled move that I admire, particularly knowing that the PHS books are such an unfathomable mess there may never be a way to sort out who paid what.

It is important to know that at the time of travel, Jenny personally paid for and produced receipts for the trip to Disneyland in California, and that Small only was responsible for a room upgrade.  

Let's be blunt - Jenny is a friend whom I greatly respect. 

If she did nothing else in her life but be one of two brave NDP MLAs - with the formidable Joy MacPhail - facing 77 howling, horrible BC Liberals after the 2001 election, raising enormous issues and fighting for social justice - she would have earned my admiration forever.

But she has been outspoken before that on Vancouver City Council and since then as an MLA, representing some of the poorest people in Canada. 

Those who criticize Jenny for trusting her spouse's word on these expenses should first consider if they have not done exactly the same. 

They should then ask - what politician would risk their reputation and career over 2 trips?

Next, ask if someone paying $35,000 in expenses she did not knowingly incur, including those of her ex-husband, is not being honourable?

There is a lot of second-guessing going on and some partisan sniping outside and inside the BC NDP but the expectation that Jenny Kwan should know more about the operations of Portland Hotel Society than the entire provincial government that funded PHS to the tune of up to $29 million a year for the past 13 years is both astonishing and ridiculous. 

In reality, this astonishing lack of accountability on the part of the BC government despite the obvious fact that the Portland Hotel Society was a high-profile, controversial and major recipient of taxpayer dollars should have screamed for attention.  

Yet it was clearly ignored.

None of this is to negate the incredibly valuable work that PHS has done in the downtown eastside.  

I respect the work done to help the poorest and most vulnerable citizens perhaps in our whole country. And I strong recommend you read a powerful piece from a PHS worker giving their perspective - which hasn't been heard in much of the media.

If you have doubts about where you stand on this, here's the take-away:

Jenny Kwan went on two trips with her partner and family.

She paid for one, except for hotel upgrades her partner said he paid for.

On the other trip, to Europe where her partner was speaking at a conference, he said he paid for the family's expenses personally.

When it turned out from the KPMG audit that there was absolutely no record or her partner having personally paid for family travel, Jenny Kwan paid all of it herself, including for her now ex-partner's share.

That in my book is honourable, it is respectful of taxpayers and the vulnerable people served by the Portland Hotel Society.

Those who carp that "she should have known" or that "she should have demanded receipts from her partner" are simply not being realistic or fair.  

As Jenny said at her news conference, being in a relationship requires a degree of trust, something those of us who have travelled with spouses can attest to. 

Ultimately, this is a sad personal situation for Jenny and to go through it in public with such vitriolic comments is an ordeal most of us will never face.

The BC NDP's longest serving MLA, the only Chinese-Canadian MLA in their caucus, someone who along with Joy MacPhail faced the most lopsided BC Legislature in history and did so with honour and courage is worthy of our understanding, not to be trashed.

I continue to support Jenny Kwan - as a dedicated MLA who fights for social justice and will keep doing so despite this challenge because she has earned my respect through her actions over the last 20 years.

.

Get Ready for Hard-to-Swallow Higher Booze Prices in BC Supermarkets - Easier To Buy, Not Cheaper

Going into the red - BC price $17.95, $15.95 in Ontario and $11.10 in Chicago!

BC Libs' changes will simply increase total sales by making it easier to buy, not cheaper.

Bill Tieleman’s 24 Hours Vancouver / The Tyee column

Tuesday March 18, 2014

By Bill Tieleman

There are only two real ways to get ahead today -- sell liquor or drink it."

- W.C. Fields, comedian, 1880-1946

Beer, wine and spirits are coming to British Columbia supermarkets next year, but don't expect cheaper booze -- if anything, what is already among North America's highest-priced alcohol will only get more expensive.

Consumers say they would love the convenience of supermarket sales, but that thrill may be gone when prices stay the same or likely go higher than in B.C. government liquor stores.

The reality of BC Liberal changes is to make booze easier to access, but prices harder to swallow.

So forget about B.C. becoming like Washington State or Europe, with giant supermarket chains offering deep discounts on your favourite beverage.

The government's real goal is simply to increase total sales by making it easier to buy, not cheaper.

The only way most prices could actually drop is if government reduced its $1-billion annual booze profits -- and that ain't gonna happen.

And since most B.C. private liquor stores already charge $2, $3 or much more per bottle of wine, spirits or a case of beer than government rates, without a wholesale price drop retail prices will stay sky high.

In fact, there is nothing in the B.C. liquor review that gives even faint hope to thirsty drinkers of any cut to the high cost of quaffing.

Booze costs already too damn high

There are two models for sales in grocery stores. The main one is called a "store within a store," where supermarkets will have a liquor sales area separated from grocery products and minors.

In addition, some B.C. VQA-certified wines will be made available at some point directly on grocery store shelves without the separate store model, though details aren't yet clear.

When this column did a price comparison of wine and beer prices in 2012, the gap between B.C. prices and other jurisdictions was stunning.

And it still is.

One example: the widely distributed Perrin Cote Du Rhone Reserve red wine sells for $17.95 a bottle in B.C. Liquor Stores, but $16.50 in Quebec government liquor stores, $15.95 in Ontario, only $13 in a private Alberta store if you buy a case of 12, and just $11.10 Canadian at Binny's in Chicago -- or $10.54 a bottle if you buy a case!

And while occasionally a B.C. bottle can be had cheaper, overall any online search will find wine, beer and spirits here are very pricey in both public and private stores.

So, government "modernizes" liquor laws, booze arrives in grocery stores, and yet the prices will only go up, not down.

Drink that irony in.

.