Tuesday, September 18, 2012

BASI-VIRK: "Stonewalling" - Auditor-General's attempt to get documents on $6 million payment to defence strongly opposed in court


More "Stonewalling" about $6 Million Legal Fees for Dave Basi and Bob Virk
Lawyer Roger McConchie and BC Conservative MLA John van Dongen outside BC Supreme Court hearing into Basi-Virk indemnity legal fees payment - Bill Tieleman photo
Auditor general, van Dongen battle lawyers to get to bottom of legal bill payment by BC tax payers

Bill Tieleman’s 24 Hours/The Tyee column
Tuesday September 18, 2012
By Bill Tieleman
"Stonewalling is a good term to use to describe this situation overall and in this case."
- John van Dongen, BC Conservative MLA
How did two former ministerial aides charged with breach of trust and fraud get their $6 million legal fees paid by the B.C. Liberal government despite pleading guilty in the B.C. Legislature Raid case?
We may never know, despite B.C.'s independent auditor general John Doyle attempting to find out through a B.C. Supreme Court application heard for five days last week.
And the hallmark of the lengthy B.C. Legislature Raid case -- delay -- emerged again, with Doyle's application first put off from June to September and now recessing until early December for final arguments, meaning Chief Justice Robert Bauman is unlikely to make a ruling until 2013.
The issue arises from one of the province's biggest political scandals ever -- with B.C. Liberal government political aides Dave Basi and Bob Virk charged with leaking confidential documents in the $1 billion privatization sale of B.C. Rail in 2003 to lobbyists for a losing bidder in exchange for money and other benefits.
Government employees facing charges can have their legal defence bills covered under a process called indemnification -- but only if they are acquitted.
But Basi and Virk made a sudden surprise guilty plea in Oct. 2010 ending their trial after hearing testimony from just two of an expected 40 witnesses -- including former and current top politicians and staff, possibly even Premier Christy Clark and former premier Gordon Campbell.
Basi and Virk had strongly protested their innocence since the case exploded with an unprecedented police raid on the B.C. Legislature in Dec. 2003 to gather evidence against the two men.
Doyle's efforts to obtain the controversial Basi-Virk legal billings and those of about 100 other government officials whose costs were indemnified since 1999 are being strongly opposed in court, primarily on the basis that solicitor-client privilege blocks his access to the billings of lawyers.
Doyle's legislative authority to conduct an audit and make recommendations to government is also being questioned.
'An incredible effort to avoid accountability'
Outside a courtroom where government is funding up to eight lawyers to argue various sides of the case, John van Dongen, a former B.C. Liberal solicitor general who quit the party in March in part because of Basi-Virk, was "very frustrated."
"There's a fair question whether this issue should be in this courtroom at all and whether it's properly motivated," van Dongen said in an exclusive interview. "There's an incredible effort to avoid accountability and transparency to taxpayers -- there's a problem here."
"Disclosure has been avoided and covered up," said van Dongen, who was given intervener status by Bauman on the grounds that his past position could add information useful to the court.
While van Dongen was a B.C. Liberal cabinet minister and insider for many years, he says he found out about the $6 million payment of legal fees the same day as the public did from then-B.C. attorney-general Mike de Jong, now finance minister.
Veteran lawyer Roger McConchie was retained by van Dongen at his own personal expense to make submissions supporting the auditor-general's application and attend the entire hearing, as did the Abbotsford-South MLA.
Perhaps ironically given the importance of the principles involved, throughout the whole hearing there were always more lawyers in the courtroom than media and observers combined.
In court, McConchie made a powerful argument that denying the auditor-general confidential access to legal billings in indemnification cases was wrong.
"Where the public interest cries out for investigation and audit, the court should be able to permit access to privileged information," McConchie told Bauman.
And McConchie said the "auditor-general plays an extremely important role" in ensuring that government spending is accountable to taxpayers.
"An audit has a sobering effect on conduct," McConchie said. "The salutary deterrent effect is that a possible audit by the auditor-general can have on ministries owes its effect to the possibility of a wide-ranging, unrestricted audit."
Auditor general's plea for access

McConchie's 50-page submission and arguments echoed those of the auditor-general's legal counsel Louis Zivot, who filed a 111-page submission with hundreds of references to case law and legislative authorities to back the application.
"It was intended by the legislation that the Auditor general have full access," Zivot told Bauman. "The legislation could have been drafted to exclude legal expenditures."
"If we have to negotiate with the attorney general as to what we can have and how we can have it, it will impede the auditor general," Zivot said.
"It is absolutely necessary that the Auditor general have access to all these documents," he said. "While a good deal of focus is on Mr. Basi and Mr. Virk... they are only two of the hundreds of recipients of indemnities."
The records that have been given to the auditor general have been severely severed or redacted, effectively rendering many of them useless, Zivot said.
"Some pages are virtually black -- you can't tell who conversations were with -- these are insufficient for auditing accounts," Zivot said. On the lectern in front of Zivot observers could clearly see a document with blacked out pages.
In concluding, Zivot warned that a decision against Doyle would not only negatively impact the B.C. auditor general's powers but those of other provinces as well, who have very similar legislative authority.
"Essentially this is a very important matter for the auditor general of British Columbia but also for other auditor generals," Zivot said. "A finding that the auditor general does not have these powers would have an adverse effect on the [B.C.] auditor general, other auditors general and auditors."
The other side
But strong arguments against the auditor general's application for these files were also heard in court.
While the government has not taken a position for or against Doyle's application, an amicus curiae or "friend of the court" was appointed by the court to oppose the auditor general's application with all relevant arguments to protect solicitor-client privilege.
Not only were lengthy arguments made in an 88-page submission strongly fighting Doyle's position but lawyer Michael Frey [pronounced Fry] previously opposed van Dongen's application for intervenor status, saying the former veteran cabinet minister had nothing to add to the case.
When it came to the auditor general's application, Frey was completely dismissive of its merits.
"The Amicus's first and foremost submission to this court is that, as a matter of statutory interpretation and law, the petitioner [Doyle] has no power to compel the abrogation of solicitor client privilege. His general production power in the [auditor general] act does not authorize the infringement of privilege," Frey wrote.
"Further, the amicus submits the petitioner has also significantly overreached in claiming that the standards justify an interpretation of the act that empowers him to compel abrogation of solicitor client privilege, or an absolute necessity for compelled interference with the privilege on any basis in connection with audit work," he continued.
Frey noted in court that Doyle's office has received partial records of indemnification legal billings that have been redacted -- or blacked out to remove some details -- and could conduct his audit with those.
Justice Bauman intervened to ask for clarification at that point.
"Is your argument that what he [the auditor general] can get through redacted material... ought to be plenty enough?" Bauman asked.
"Yes," Frey quickly responded.
Mysterious Sandra Harper
Basi and Virk are also opposing the auditor general -- at least in part. They have given a partial waiver on access to those documents possessed by government -- but not the files of two lawyers retained to independently review the legal bills of Michael Bolton, lawyer for Basi and Kevin McCullough, lawyer for Virk.
And as always with the B.C. Legislature raid case, efforts to find out what happened invariably uncover yet more mysteries.
One of the lawyers attending the full five-day hearing was Sandra Harper, one of the independent reviewers of Basi and Virk's legal costs.
Harper took the stand briefly to explain her position: that she declined to provide her files to the auditor general when he requested them, saying that while she did not object, Virk did, and so Doyle should seek a court order for her to produce them.
But things took a strange turn in her testimony on Sept. 12.
"I acted as the independent reviewer of counsel for the accused, Mr. Basi and Mr. Virk, until Sept. 2010, when I resigned," she told Bauman.
What? The only independent reviewer of the $6 million in legal fees for the accused for five years quits just weeks before the actual trial starts in Oct. 2010?
Naturally, I wanted to know why, and approached Harper as she left court on a break Friday.
Tieleman: "Bill Tieleman, with 24 hours newspaper and The Tyee, Ms. Harper -- may I ask you one simple question?"
Harper: "No."
Tieleman: "But don't you even want to know the question?"
Harper: "I won't be talking to the media. You may find out the answers through others at the court."
And with that she was gone, leaving the puzzle additionally intriguing.
But wait, there's more.
Harper also publicly opposed van Dongen's application for intervenor status when it was made in May.
"It's so politically motivated and so off topic that I'm very concerned that Mr. van Dongen's real message is not inside court but outside court and there's a very real concern of the application becoming politicized," she said then. "The Basi-Virk matter has been political enough."
That view didn't hold sway with Bauman, who granted van Dongen's request, saying: "I am satisfied that a responsible intervention will be made."
But it's hard for this case to avoid being "political" when the co-accused were both senior B.C. Liberal ministerial assistants who leaked confidential government material not only to lobbyists Erik Bornmann and Brian Kieran -- who were never charged and were slated to become key Crown witnesses -- but also to Bruce Clark, the premier's own brother, who also was never charged with any offence.
So why is Sandra Harper not willing to tell the public why she quit as the reviewer of Basi and Virk’s legal bills?
And why did she openly oppose van Dongen's application for intervenor status?
Hard to know when Harper won't even hear questions, let alone answer them.
But there's no record of Harper making political donations to any party on the Elections BC financial reporting website.
Fog has yet to lift
And so the mysteries continue nearly nine years after the Basi-Virk/B.C. Legislature raid case first exploded into public view.
Since that time the overall costs to the public have topped $18 million, including prosecution and RCMP expenditures as well as Basi and Virk's legal bills.
Overall, it's clear that win or lose, the auditor general's application will not be able to answer the much larger questions of what happened when the government sold the publicly-owned B.C. Rail that it has promised in 2001 to keep.
That's why it's worth continuing to call for a public inquiry, which has been supported by the B.C. New Democrats, the B.C. Conservatives and the B.C. Green Party.
You can add your voice at the Facebook page -- Basi-Virk Public Inquiry.
But until and unless that inquiry takes place, there are too many mysteries and not enough clues.

.

Thursday, September 13, 2012

BASI-VIRK: Auditor General battles in court to get access to government indemnity documents

Auditor General John Doyle's difficult road to get access to Basi-Virk/BC Legislature Raid legal indemnity documents faces government roadblocks
David Basi - far left - and Bob Virk - far right after entering guilty pleas in October 2010

In a nearly empty BC Supreme Court room where there are more government-paid lawyers - seven at least - than either media members or public observers, a serious legal street fight is being waged over access to confidential government documents sought by the independent Auditor General.

At stake - accountability to taxpayers and transparency in the expenditure of millions in government funds.

Specifically, Doyle is attempting to find out how the $6 million legal fees of David Basi and Bob Virk were paid by the government despite the two former BC Liberal Ministerial aides pleading guilty to breach of trust and fraud charges.

Government officials can be "indemnified" for their legal fees if they face charges related to the conduct of their duties - but only so long as they are found innocent.

In the BC Legislature Raid case, Basi and Virk admitted receiving money and other benefits in exchange for leaking confidential government documents related to the $1 billion privatization of BC Rail to lobbyists working for one of the bidders.

But in addition, there are nearly 100 other cases of government employees receiving millions in legal fees for indemnification.

And it appears there are no clear policies or even guidelines on how these funds were spent.

That is the purpose of Doyle's attempt to conduct a value for money audit - but it has been steadfastly opposed by the government.

On  Wednesday at court in front of Chief Justice Robert Bauman arguments for Doyle were made by lawyer Louis Zivot, who stated that the Auditor General Act was clearly drafted to give Doyle access to whatever government documents his office needs to conduct audits.

The key argument against letting Doyle have confidential files is that it violates solicitor-client privilege, but Zivot rejected that claim.

"It was intended by the legislation that the Auditor General have full access," Zivot told Bauman.  "The legislation could have been drafted to exclude legal expenditures."

"If we have to negotiate with the attorney general as to what we can have and how we can have it, it will impede the Auditor General," Zivot said.

"It is absolutely necessary that the Auditor General have access to all these documents," he said. "While a good deal of focus is on Mr. Basi and Mr. Virk... they are only two of the hundreds of recipients of indemnities."

The records that have been given to the Auditor General have been severely severed or redacted, effectively rendering many of them useless, Zivot said.

"Some pages are virtually black - you can't tell who conversations were with - these are insufficient for auditing accounts," Zivot said.  On the lectern in front of Zivot observers could clearly see a document with blacked out pages.

In concluding, Zivot warned that a decision against Doyle would not only negatively impact the BC Auditor General's powers but those of other provinces as well, who have very similar legislative authority.

"Essentially this is a very important matter for the Auditor General of British Columbia but also for other auditor generals," Zivot said. "A finding that the Auditor General does not have these powers would have an adverse effect on the Auditor General, other auditors general and auditors."

NOTE TO READERS - Veteran lawyer Roger McConchie made powerful arguments on behalf of BC Conservative MLA John van Dongen later on Wednesday.  Those arguments and an interview with van Dongen will be the subject of my 24 Hours/The Tyee column on Tuesday September 18 - along with other information from the hearing on Thursday and Friday.

.









Tuesday, September 11, 2012

BASI-VIRK: Auditor General application for government legal defence indemnity documents continues

WATCH FOR UPDATE THURSDAY ON JOHN VAN DONGEN'S LEGAL ARGUMENTS IN COURT MADE WEDNESDAY

Sorry - overwhelmed with work but I was in Court for Roger McConchie's submission on behalf of MLA John van Dongen and will post an article sometime Thursday, as well as comments from van Dongen.

ORIGINAL POST:

An application by BC Auditor General John Doyle for access to government records regarding the $6 million payment of legal fees for the defence in the Basi-Virk/BC Legislature Raid case continued to be heard today in BC Supreme Court.


Lawyer Roger McConchie and BC Conservative MLA John van Dongen outside BC Supreme Court hearing - Bill Tieleman photo
Doyle's lawyer Louis Zivot resumed his argument for access to documents the Auditor General says his office needs to examine the reasons why former BC Liberal ministerial aides Dave Basi and Bob Virk had their legal bills of $6 million over several years paid despite pleading guilty to breach of trust and fraud over leaking confidential documents to lobbyists for a bidder for BC Rail in 2003.

That $1 billion privatization led to an unprecedented police raid on the BC Legislature and a lengthy pre-trial hearing that I covered extensively, followed by an abbreviated trial that ended after only two witnesses testified - when Basi and Virk suddenly pled guilty after years of declaring their innocence.

Zivot's 113-page affidavit is a lengthy examination of both the BC Auditor General Act and other Canadian legislation regarding the powers of auditors general and their ability to obtain the information necessary for audits.

"The Auditor General must be able to obtain such record as to be reasonably informed on these matters," Zivot argued before Chief Justice Robert Bauman.

Former BC Liberal Solicitor General John van Dongen - who quit the party to become the BC Conservatives only MLA - is attending the application and has intervenor status.  His lawyer Roger McConchie - hired at van Dongen's personal expense - is expected to make his arguments on Wednesday morning. 

Van Dongen said in an interview with me Monday that he is unhappy with the BC Liberal government's steadfast refusal to release documents sought by the Auditor General.

"It's very frustrating - That's one of the reason's why I applied for intervenor status," van Dongen said.

The hearing is expected to continue through Friday in courtroom 32.


Fans plan boycott campaign against NHL owners' businesses if lockout happens September 15

Will You Join the Hockey Fan's Revolt By Boycotting NHL Owners' others businesses if there's a lockout?


If Vancouver Canucks players like Daniel Sedin are put in the penalty box by owners, fans want to drop the gloves and be third man into the fight! - Bill Tieleman photo
Fans hatch plan to penalize NHL owners' businesses if they lock out players and risk the season

Bill Tieleman’s 24 hours/The Tyee column

Tuesday September 11, 2012

By Bill Tieleman

View full article and comments:

"Oh! The good old hockey game / Is the best game you can name."

- Stompin' Tom Connors - "The Hockey Song"

A group of dedicated National Hockey League fans won't cry in their beer if team owners lock out their players. They are planning to take billionaire owners into the boards very hard.

How? By launching a consumer boycott of NHL team owners' other businesses -- including breweries and restaurant chains -- to penalize them for high sticking fans.

The website was set up along with a Facebook page and Twitter account to let fans take things into their own hands and wallets as a potentially lengthy lockout starts Sept. 15.

Rebellion of the '10,000aires'

The You Have Two Weeks campaign -- named because it was launched two weeks before the planned lockout -- has detailed NHL owners' other holdings as targets.

Those include high profile B.C. businesses like Denny's Restaurants, Moxies' Classic Grill, the Shark Club and Sandman Hotels -- all ventures of Dallas Stars' owner Tom Gaglardi, while Vancouver Canucks' owner Francesco Aquilini and his family's development empire is also listed.

Other major NHL franchises targeted include Toronto Maple Leafs' owners Bell Canada and Rogers Communications and Montreal Canadians' owner Molson Coors Brewing Company.

And while the fans behind the campaign say they aren't out to change the world, they are concerned about who will really get hurt by a lockout.

"I'm not trying to make this a noble cause -- we just want to watch hockey," T.J. Tully said in a Sunday interview from Edmonton, where he is a big Oilers fan.

But Tully points out that in addition to fans missing their good old hockey game, the real victims will be the thousands of modest income workers who have jobs at NHL arenas across North America.

"It's the millionaires fighting the billionaires but they're hurting the $10,000aires who work at the arenas selling food and beer and cleaning up," Tully says.

"The owners aren't worried about them. It's just one more corporate decision for hundreds of millions of dollars, but they don't see the real-life consequences," he said.

Just cut a deal

Tully says that the hockey season could start on time and negotiations continue simultaneously if it weren't for NHL commissioner Gary Bettman.

"I believe the owners could play under the old CBA [Collective Bargaining Agreement] but Gary Bettman decided to go to a lockout," Tully said.

"Bettman told the owners, 'Fans came running back after the last lockout -- so let's lock the players out, maximize our leverage and the fans will come back again afterwards,'" Tully reasons.

So to balance the pressure, Tully and three friends set up the campaign to make the owners also face some heat -- since players won't have any income if a lockout starts.

But Tully says his group isn't really taking the players' side either.

"We have all this leverage on the owners and none on the players," he said.

Ultimately, Tully says, his campaign could just make the difference between a long, bitter lockout or a return to the rink on time for a full season.

"If we can convince even one owner to change their vote, it's worthwhile," he said.

The low budget campaign -- the website cost $100 and "a case of Stella" to put together -- is taking on some of the richest business people in the world, but that doesn't deter Tully.

And he isn't planning on getting rich off the campaign.

"We have no intention at all to make money on this website," Tully says, noting there aren't even ads on it.

But Tully and his friends think that their one penalty shot at owners just might score the winning goal.
 
.


 

Monday, September 10, 2012

BASI-VIRK returns! Auditor-General John Doyle's BC Supreme Court application for indemnification documents begins today

Basi-Virk case revisited - BC Auditor-General John Doyle legal application for government documents in BC Rail $6 million legal indemnification of Dave Basi and Bob Virk defence begins at BC Supreme Court
Bill Tieleman - returns to the scene of the BC Rail crime trial - at BC Supreme Court
BC Conservative MLA John van Dongen attends court hearing with intervenor status - expresses "frustration" with provincial government he was once part of for delaying release of needed files

BC Chief Justice Robert Bauman opened a 5-day hearing in BC Supreme Court this morning to rule on an unprecedented application by BC's independent Auditor General John Doyle to get government documents related to the Basi-Virk/BC Legislature Raid case.

Doyle is examining the $6 million indemnification of legal defence costs paid by the BC Liberal government despite former ministerial aides Dave Basi and Bob Virk eventually pleading guilty to breach of trust and fraud charges they faced for several years.

The sudden guilty plea bargain deal in October 2010 after just two witnesses testified in the case shocked the province and left the odds of finding out what really happened in the $1 billion sale of BC Rail in 2003 in grave doubt.

Doyle is trying to find out how Basi and Virk were able to negotiate their legal fees being paid when government policy is to only indemnify those costs when the accused are found not guilty.

Former BC Liberal Solicitor General and MLA John van Dongen - who quit the party and joined the BC Conservatives earlier this year - is attending the court hearing and has been granted official intervenor status.  Veteran lawyer Roger McConchie is representing van Dongen in court at the MLA's expense.

I spoke to van Dongen outside court when the hearing adjourned for lunch.

"It's very frustrating.  That's one of the reasons I applied for intervenor status," van Dongen said.  "It's very important that the Auditor General have full and unfettered access under his Act to all the documents he needs."

Van Dongen said the entire indemnity program for BC government employees - Doyle is seeking information on 99 indemnification agreements going back 15 years - is "something of an ad hoc process" based on information provided in Court so far.

"The special indemnity program has evolved over time with little elected official involvement," van Dongen said.

And he said that just like the previous multi-year pre-trial hearing process: "The pattern has been often one of delays."

The hearing resumes this afternoon and is scheduled to continue daily through Friday.

I will be speaking with Jon McComb of CKNW AM 980 at about 4:15 p.m. today about this hearing.

UPDATE - 5 p.m. - I was able to attend part of Monday afternoon's hearing - and was the only media member there at the end of the day.  I can report that the content was less than exciting - Auditor General John Doyle's lawyer Louis Zivot gave a thorough reading of case law and legislation regarding Auditor Generals across Canada with special attention to the BC Auditor General Act but it was a bit far from scintillating for most observers - and there were very few.

I had another discussion with BC Conservative MLA John van Dongen and his lawyer Roger McConchie at the end of the session and they expect it to go the full 5 days scheduled.

I will be in attendance again Tuesday as time permits and will file another posting then.

.

.

Tuesday, September 04, 2012

BC Liberal levee breaks: cabinet minister, MLA departures a vote of non-confidence in Christy Clark


BC Liberal levee breaks: MLAs flowing out
And then there was one - Christy Clark wins leadership, George Abbott and Kevin Falcon lose and now leave.
UPDATE 5 p.m. : Transportation Minister Blair Lekstrom, MLAs Joan McIntyre, Rob Howard pack it in too!  Now up to 13 MLAs leaving BC Liberals.

For Christy Clark, It Keeps Getting Lonelier at the Top with BC Liberal exodus is a non-confidence vote in premier's leadership, no matter the spin.

Bill Tieleman’s 24 hours/The Tyee column

Tuesday September 4, 2012

By Bill Tieleman

Now, cryin' won't help you, prayin' won't do you no good / When the levee breaks, mama, you got to move."
- Led Zeppelin: "When The Levee Breaks" [Originally written by Memphis Minnie & Kansas Joe McCoy]
The BC Liberal levee broke last week and by the end of political hurricane season many of its MLAs will be adrift, not running for re-election.
The sudden resignations of Finance Minister Kevin Falcon and Education Minister George Abbott in just 24 hours only indicates the extreme severity of the storm Premier Christy Clark faces, not its length.
The departure of Clark's two closest leadership rivals in 2011's contest is more than just a case of planned retirement -- it is a non-confidence vote in Clark, no matter how much they deny it.
Add in last week's announcement that Children and Family Development Minister Mary McNeil and Clark's Parliamentary Secretary John Les also won't run, and the running total is 10 sitting B.C. Liberal MLAs bowing out [now 12].
Expect more announcements soon from other B.C. Liberals who won't run again in the May 2013 election.
UPDATE - 10 a.m.: Tuesday morning brings news that BC Liberal MLAs Joan McIntyre and Rob Howard will not run again in 2013.  Cabinet minister Rich Coleman will run, he announced today also. 

After all, with the B.C. NDP at 45 per cent in recent polls and the B.C. Liberals at just 23 per cent with the B.C. Conservatives under leader John Cummins narrowly behind at 22 per cent, most of Clark's MLAs can expect to lose their seats barring a miracle turnaround
"I do expect there will be some more [resignations]. I have had those conversations with those people," Clark herself admitted to media last week.
And those remaining B.C. Liberals face a difficult challenge, according to Vernon-Monashee MLA Eric Foster.
"The ship isn't sinking," Foster has said. "It's our job to make sure people know this isn't the case."
Not sinking? There's an awful lot of water on the decks.
Previous tidal waves
In the last two election tsunamis that all but wiped out the New Democrat government in 2001 and the Social Credit administration in 1991, each party had 15 sitting MLAs decline to face voters.
Odds are the BC Liberals will match or beat that total, making the unflattering comparison inevitable.
On the plus side, 24 [now 25]sitting MLAs -- including Clark -- have stated their intention to run again, based on media reports.
That leaves eight caucus members yet to announce their plans, including former finance minister Colin Hansen -- co-author of the Harmonized Sales Tax with ex-premier Gordon Campbell, current cabinet ministers Rich Coleman [now staying], Mary Polak, Blair Lekstrom, and Ida Chong and backbenchers Joan McIntyre [now not running], Randy Hawes, and Rob Howard  [now not running].
Since Clark will shuffle her cabinet this week and says only those running again will be appointed, some MLAs made their choice this past long weekend and informed the premier.
'We've got a question of leadership'
But there's more trouble than just MLA departures. Former B.C. Liberal strategist Alise Mills suggested on CBC Radio last Wednesday that Falcon's resignation indicates senior government members don't have confidence in Clark.
Alise Mills
"If George Abbott leaves tomorrow as is widely rumoured, that adds a lot of credibility on what Kevin Falcon did today and now we've got a question of leadership. We don't have a question of partisan game playing, we have a question of leadership," said Mills, a former Falcon leadership campaign supporter who is no longer a BC Liberal Party member.
"I'm not going to be popular amongst BC Liberals for saying this but I do think there was a break, a crack in ideology between the premier and the finance minister. I think one had one direction, one had another," Mills told host Stephen Quinn.
Another indication of Clark's conundrum is that Falcon publicly pledged during that contest he would run for the BC Liberals in 2013, even goading Clark when she refused to make the same promise.
"Christy, I've made a commitment to run in this election win or lose, so whether I win or lose [the leadership] I'm going to be a candidate for this party," Falcon said.
Now he's breaking that word and regardless of changed personal circumstances -- he and wife Jessica expect a second child in February -- Falcon clearly has more than family reasons for leaving.
Will right unite?
And what does the future hold for the political right? Will the BC Conservatives jump past the lackluster Liberals and become official opposition to a BC NDP government and the go-to choice for the centre right in 2017?
Will the B.C. Liberals survive to fight another day? Or will the two parties then merge as has happened before in provincial political history?
Much speculation is taking place amongst right-wing political activists and B.C. Liberal business backers, many of whom are already conceding the 2013 ballot to NDP leader Adrian Dix.
Leave the last word to Mills as to the political future after the election: "I don't think the BC Liberal Party will exist."

.

Wednesday, August 29, 2012

Departing BC Finance Minister Kevin Falcon's dreary record "highlighted" by HST

UPDATED: 4 BC Liberal MLAs gone in 24 hours: George Abbott, Mary McNeill, John less join Kevin Falcon in bailing out.

BC Finance Minister Kevin Falcon reaches the end of the line with little to show for term in Christy Clark government except extending period with hated Harmonized Sales Tax

Getting off at next station: first Gordon Campbell and now Kevin Falcon.
UPDATE #3: At 1:15 p.m. I join host Mike Smyth on CKNW AM 980 to talk about the Kevin Falcon, George Abbott, Mary McNeill & John Les resignations and announcements they won't run in the next election. Tune in!

UPDATE#2: I will be talking to CBC TV News Network host Reshmi Nair NOW at 12:40 pm BC time on Kevin Falcon, George Abbott resignations.

UPDATE #1: BC Liberal Education Minister George Abbott, Children and Family Development Minister Mary McNeill and MLA John Les, Parliamentary Secretary to Premier Christy Clark, are all expected to announce Thursday morning they will not run again in the next provincial election.

Abbott will be the second BC Liberal leadership candidate in 24 hours to quit Clark's government, following Finance Minister Kevin Falcon's resignation Wednesday.  More to come......

ORIGINAL POSTING WEDNESDAY:

After losing the BC Liberal leadership to Christy Clark, Kevin Falcon could say: "I used to be the next Premier of British Columbia!" to rephrase Al Gore's funniest line.

But now Falcon is gone even as finance minister and whether he will ever get another chance to be premier is very dubious at best.

After all, BC Liberals declined to give him the job last year because he was seen as less electable than Clark and carrying too much baggage from his former boss Gordon Campbell.

Some think Falcon is using the same strategy successfully employed by Jean Chretien, John Turner, Bill Vander Zalm and many other politicians who left the electoral arena for a few years only to come back as leaders of their parties.

Maybe so - and I do give Falcon's stated reason for leaving - to support his wife as she gives birth to their second child - considerable weight.

On the other hand, Falcon repeatedly goaded Clark during the leadership over her refusal to run for the BC Liberals in the next election if she lost that contest - saying he'd be running either way. 

Now he's not.  Falcon is allowed to change his mind and particularly when circumstances change significantly.  But I have to think that just like Christy Clark when she lost the NPA nomination for Vancouver mayor in 2005, Kevin Falcon's ambition has not altered either - he still wants to be premier.

Unfortunately for the now simply MLA for Surrey-Cloverdale, his record in office under Clark is rather bereft of good news.

Falcon will best be known for continuing the lengthy period that British Columbians were charged the Harmonized Sales Tax despite soundly rejecting it in the 2011 binding referendum.

Falcon's steadfast defence of the indefensible tax and chippy comments after the referendum that he would be reintroducing a "stupid tax" - the PST - to replace it, isn't a legacy to bring up with voters in a few years and expect glowing memories.

Nor is BC's huge $1.84 billion deficit something to be proud of as finance minister.  Yes, repayment of the HST federal grant is part of that amount but it was the BC Liberals that panicked in 2009 when they saw a deficit 6 times bigger than they promised and then introduced the HST to get that money in the first place.

The other rumour is that Falcon will run for the federal Conservatives in the 2015 federal election somewhere in Surrey.  A credible theory at least.

But in the meantime, regardless of his record or my politics, I do wish Kevin and his family well in the future.  Agree or disagree with his policies but everyone who gives time to public service deserves our thanks.

.